Pirates ! French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD
The French satirical investigative journalism weekly “Le Canard Enchaîné“ reveals that our holier-than-thou presidency is in fact a pirate’s lair. In a stunning display of hypocrisy, the presidential audiovisual services produced 400 unauthorized copies of the 52 minutes documentary “A visage découvert : Nicolas Sarkozy“.
The editor, Galaxie Press had only shipped 50 copies, but the propaganda plan required more so the Elysee went to work, going as far as modifying the cover and replacing the Galaxie Presse name and logos with “Service audiovisuel de la présidence de la République”.
Isn’t is deliciously ironic that the same executive power is the main force behind the latest disgusting bungled piece of French legislation regulating and controlling the usage of the Internet in order to enforce the compliance to the copyright law ?

It is even more appalling that we are dealing with repeat offenders : last spring, while the Hadopi law was discussed, U.S. music duo MGMT received €30,000 as a settlement for a copyright infringement by French President Nicolas Sarkozy’s party who used one of its songs at a political rally without permission. Those who led the charge against Internet users are not the most respectful of copyright.
Hadopi is also known as the “three strikes” law because it after a certain number of warnings a copyright infringer’s Internet access would be cut off. Hadopi has just been adopted. Nicolas – one more of those antics and your Internet access is toast !
7 Comments
1 Comment
75 Tweets
52 Other Comments
165 Responses to “Pirates ! French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD”
Leave a Reply
Additional comments powered by BackType
French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko… #hadopi #france
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
glynmoody
RT @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko…
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
vendorprisey
RT @glynmoody French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko…
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
alicekaerast
Schadenfreude RT @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z #threestrike #hadopi #france
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
edent
RT @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD -http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far #hadopi #france
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
nzlemming
French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko. (via @alicekaerast)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
security4all
RT @glynmoody French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko…
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
stealthmunchkin
RT @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, Filz ist überall, Rom, Paris, Br…….
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Bruchsal2009
RT: @edent: Schadenfreude RT @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z #fb
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
warpcafe
R: @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes #hadopi #france
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
br3nda
RT @security4all: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko.
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
thierryzoller
♺ @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko…
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
larusalka
RT @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far #hadopi #france
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
elpie
http://bit.ly/5n5zD via @addthis
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
xregisx
#threestrikes Sarkozy pirates 400 DVD’s http://bit.ly/96LEZ
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
doodlewhale
shares http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz (French presidency confirmed for copyright piracy). How ironic http://plurk.com/p/276zja
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
gabecube
Pirates! RT @newsycombinator: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://bit.ly/18MZyB
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
ln4711
RT @newsycombinator French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://bit.ly/18MZyB
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
behe
French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD… http://bit.ly/4kOCHr
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
hackernewsbot
French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://is.gd/44Xiu (via @angsuman)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
nlcluigi
HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
astronewth
RT @astronewth: HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
ctolsen
When the presidency does it, that means that it is not illegal.
This comment was originally posted on Reddit
InsanityInversion
RT @astronewth: HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
aslakr
Lifestream: » French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://bit.ly/y6VY5
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
jtyost2lifestrm
RT @astronewth: HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
olemartin
:-)
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Catriona
RT @astronewth: HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
jarannilsen
RT @astronewth: HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Erik_nufsaid
“Pirates ! French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD” http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
CopyrightLaw
Hmm! RT @glynmoody French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko..
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
DeeSobek
French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/17Sa3a One more mistake & HADOPI kicks in. Sarkozy without internett.
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
TheMusicMan81
Sarkozy rips 400 DVDs: http://bit.ly/zqFQI Once more, and he’s off the net!
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
JuliuzBeezer
RT @astronewth: HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
dozern77
HNews: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://bit.ly/48BvnA
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
tek_news
Pirates ! French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://bit.ly/eib1S
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
PierreTran
HoHo! RT @astronewth HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
svennra
“hadopi sarko et se sdvd ça twitte beaucoup à l’étranger http://bit.ly/3LM3PR
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
nico2gan
french presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of dvd: 2nd strike for nicolas sarkozy: http://tr.im/B6Pg #hadopi #fail
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
jotbe
Das ist doch nichts neues… hat man dir noch nicht gesagt, das Gesetze nur für Leute gelten, die unter 20k$ verdienen?
This comment was originally posted on http://www.nerdcore.de/wp)“>Nerdcore
The Juice Weasel
http://bit.ly/4lNpyp
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
pyr3
French president violates own piracy law. http://bit.ly/4lNpyp
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
jayturley
come al solito… chi predica bene… razzola male…!
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Jul_x
RT @astronewth HADOPI-pappa Sarkozy bryter åndsverkloven. I stor skala, for å gjøre hykleriet fullkomment: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
TiramT
peiiiinlich!
This comment was originally posted on http://www.nerdcore.de/wp)“>Nerdcore
finefin
RT @nico2gan “hadopi sarko et se sdvd ça twitte beaucoup à l’étranger http://bit.ly/3LM3PR
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
jeymer
Father of HADOPI, Sarkozy, is breaking copyrights http://bit.ly/EeIgL (via @astronewth). Brown did the same in 2008 http://bit.ly/bAmL4
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
benteka
SKANDAL!
This comment was originally posted on http://www.nerdcore.de/wp)“>Nerdcore
KAERF
Hah, loving http://bit.ly/4kOCHr ! CopyrightLawFAIL.
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
blakjaknz
French Presidency makes 400 unauthorised copies of DVDs: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz (via #NSWYL)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
kennethti
Absolutely priceless. RT @kennethti: French Presidency makes 400 unauthorised copies of DVDs: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz (via #NSWYL)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
vorondil
» Pirates ! French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://bit.ly/GoOuw
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
j5i
GReading: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD: Comments http://bit.ly/17L5LV
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
andrewbadera
@finefin: Glaubst du echt, diesen Berlusconis ist was peinlich?
This comment was originally posted on http://www.nerdcore.de/wp)“>Nerdcore
Kenny
Französische Regierung kopiert unerlaubterweise Dokufilm: http://tinyurl.com/ybovuvg via Nerdcore #Hadopi #Sarkozy #piracy
This comment was originally posted on http://www.nerdcore.de/wp)“>Nerdcore
rockthebiz (Marc Weissenberger)
RT @glynmoody: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko…
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
padowi
joé con ’sarko’. tanta historia, y va a ser que también le mola ir de pirata… http://bit.ly/UxgtH
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
chechar
RT @rockthebiz: Französische Regierung kopiert unerlaubterweise Dokufilm: http://tinyurl.com/ybovuvg via Nerdcore #Hadopi #Sarkozy #piracy
This comment was originally posted on http://www.nerdcore.de/wp)“>Nerdcore
kugelsack_info (Radio Kugelsack.fm)
To quote William Shakespeare, "Hoist with his own petard."
Kick him off the internet.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Ed Woychowsky
and fine him 50000 euro for each infringing copy!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Rabbit80
RT @kugelsack_info: RT @rockthebiz: Französische Regierung kopiert unerlaubterweise Dokufilm: http://tinyurl.com/ybovuvg via Nerdcore
This comment was originally posted on http://www.nerdcore.de/wp)“>Nerdcore
nicola_e2009 (Nicola)
Unfortunately, why do I get the feeling that Sarkozy won’t change his stance one bit — or even recognize the irony of the situation?
Because that’s not what his corporate overlords are paying him for. They are paying him to pass laws that defy common sense no matter what era in time you are from.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Killer_Tofu
I agree. I think a personal fine of 20,000,000 Euros should probably be enough to remove all the money he received from his corporate overlords.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
imbrucy
"Why is it always the adamant defenders of silly policies like kicking people off the internet for copyright infringement who are later found to be mass infringers themselves?"
Uh, well, I usually like to go off on massive diatribes with tons of quotes and so forth, but this one can be answered simply:
Because most of them are politicians and politicians as a rule are absolutely 100% mega full of shit.
Next question, please….
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Dark Helmet
Most laws dont apply to French politicians,though.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Mechwarrior
In my experience, politicians never seem to notice that laws also apply to them. Didn’t know that that’s actually true in France. Gaming the system is easy. If you make the laws, why make them apply to you? For instance, where I live a member of congress has a limited set of driving rules applying to them (much like ambulances and police cars do, but it makes sense for ambulances and police cars).
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
The problem of P2P is not the copyright infringement is that everybody, anybody can do it so the distribution of information and art is not controllable anymore. The editor-distribution music companies want the control to gain money from the scarcity created by the control and the politician want to control it because thats what all politician want control. Imagine the mess if the politician would have to explain themselves not only to other politician and a couple of journalist but to everybody with a internet conection
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
While I agree that people infringe without meaning to all the time, this is different. He knowing copied a DVD 400 times AND removed production credit from the case. This is clearly a criminal act.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
maclizard
He will claim he did not know and some poor little guy will have to take the fall for him.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Bryan
While this is a very worthy revelation about a two-bit hypocrite, this is actually not as much about "piracy" as it is counterfeiting. Yes, he probably "pirated" the source, but once you step out of just file-sharing and go into production, and even removing/changing credits on the covers, you have moved beyond simple infringement into a REAL criminal arena. I would venture to say that counterfeiting is a far worse crime than sharing. Of course, copyright maximalists will disagree, and say that "if it werent for piracy!" etc. being the indoctrined sheep they are.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
RD
"Unfortunately, why do I get the feeling that Sarkozy won’t change his stance one bit — or even recognize the irony of the situation?"
Because he is a politician (liar), has no ethics (sleazeball), and takes the hipocritic oath he swore to when he first ran for public office quite seriously…
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
spaceman spiff
he’d probably use taxpayer money to pay for it in an indirect fashion.
coming up with 30 thou euro and clearly not even batting an eye is a ton of money.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Designerfx
He should resign…the world should boycott Belgium until he does.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Michael Lockyear
Unfortunately, why do I get the feeling that Sarkozy won’t change his stance one bit — or even recognize the irony of the situation?
Because he’s French and the leader of one of the G8.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
Lily, Sarkozy, wonder who’s next?
Michael Lockyear … eh, he’s French.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
JP_Fife
Kick him off the planet…
No soup for you!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Shuryno
Um, he’s French. Leave Belgium alone, they make wonderful beer.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Eponymous Coward, AKA Doug
Yeah, because we all know that an American President would change his stance and admit doing wrong…
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Free Capitalist
I’ve changed my mind, I’m with Michael on this one: Boycott Belgium until Sarkozy resigns from the German Parliament. And while we’re at it let’s ask the Dutch to send soldiers into the Netherlands and drive out the invaders from Holland.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
JP_Fife
He cannot be accused to anything while he is president. So he has green lights to keep pirating and distributing illegal copies without fear of anything:
Article 67 : The President of The Republic is not responsable for acts accomplised in this quality, [...].
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
Even in the eyes of the MPAA, RIAA and their international counterparts, "piracy" isn’t just about copying things online, that’s just the latest iteration. This guy isn’t just a pirate because he copied the movie, he took the next step and took credit for the movie.
He didn’t step out of the piracy arena by stepping into the criminal arena, he stepped further into the piracy arena while stepping into the criminal arena (they overlap).
Even if copyright was limited back to the way it was, this guy would still be slammed by it.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Chronno S. Trigger
What a prick!
The funniest thing is that if they’d produced the documentary themselves and stuck it on a p2p network it would have got far more views anyway!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Sheinen
Kick’em off the World Wide EARTH!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
"Why is it always the adamant defenders of silly policies like kicking people off the internet for copyright infringement who are later found to be mass infringers themselves?"
Because they see copyright as a fence – with us at one side and them at the other. The copyright laws don’t apply on "their" side of the fence unless they are in their favour!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Rabbit80
Ah, you funny US americans with your canadian tacos.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
yup, If anyone else pirates it , it loses its vAlue to them!
Like I said,
Kick’em off the World Wide EARTH!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
One more act of piracy and Le President should lose his net priveleges: http://bit.ly/5n5zD
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
bpmurray
How can you implement anti-piracy laws in France when the president himself violates it?! http://bit.ly/4lNpyp
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
tinabargo
Why kick him off the internet? Did they do this on the internet?
Mike REEEEEEEACHES again.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
French president Sarkozy breaks own copyright laws – again. This time producing 400 pirate DVDs! http://ow.ly/tzUF
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
randomhuman
Nicolas ‘Three-Strike’ Sarkozy mass-pirates DVDs. The presidential service produced 400 copies of a documentary. http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
thijsniks
French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko… #hadopi
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
p01
RT: @p01: French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD – http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z well, that’s two strikes so far for Sarko… #hadopi
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
psenough
But on the next strike, I expect the hacker communities of the world to join together to DDOS the French president’s internet connection….
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
PRMan
Look, up in the sky, over there, above your head, it’s the point!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
Yeah, and you reeeeeeach around on your mum
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Sheinen
#sarkozy has two strikes down, on strike to go: http://bit.ly/4lNpyp #hadopi
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
brthur
Sarkozy faz 400 cópias ilegais de dvds: http://ow.ly/tBfk #tropadeelite
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
andretaf
@relche Sarkozy beim Raubkopieren erwischt: http://bit.ly/5n5zD via @addthis schon das 2. Mal. Beim 3. Mal gibt’s Internetsperre !
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
i_peter
Enquanto isso, será que tem nobel de hipocrisia pro pirata do Sarkozy? http://bit.ly/3zq9Gm #pirate #threestrikes
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
gwidion
RT @gwidion: Enquanto isso, será que tem nobel de hipocrisia pro pirata do Sarkozy? http://bit.ly/3zq9Gm #pirate #threestrikes
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
cesaraovivo
RT @cesaraovivo/@gwidion: Enquanto isso, será que tem nobel de hipocrisia pro pirata do Sarkozy? http://3.ly/739 #pirate #hadopi
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
joaosergio
Good point. How did they distribute these then, by mail? Fine, he should not be allowed to use the mail anymore, neither sending nor receiving. Or was it by truck? OK, no more automobiles for Sarkozy, he can bike or take the subway.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
nasch
Aaa evet, o da vardı… Galiba fuhuş da Bologne ormanındaki travestilerle idi… :)))
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Ozgur Uckan
Dolaysıyla en azından Fransa’da telif hakları ihlalinin çocuk pornografisinden daha tehlikeli olduğunu anlamış bulunuyoruz!
This comment was originally posted on FriendFeed
Ozgur Uckan
The people ought to make money with information have invested interest to shackle down the internet. The evil-doers.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
clay
If you kick him off the internet then in turn he could kick you off the internet
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Thomas
lol! The French president is a pirate – http://tr.im/Bjhi
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
wilburlikesmith
Pirates! French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD http://su.pr/974aBx One more strike and your out Mr. Sarkozy!
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
rtaibah
Three Strikes contre le Petit Nicolas? Französisches Präsidialamt raubkopiert 400 DVDs http://bit.ly/4lNpyp
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
zynaesthesie
Intentional!
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Michael Lockyear
Searched my house for Belgian, French or German products I could toss on to the bonfire of my disgust…sadly couldn’t find any (what DO these guys do for money?)…I really do hope that the Scots never do or say anything stupid as I would really hate to boycott their fine exports :)
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Michael Lockyear
Ban this copyright thief from the internet immediately please Lord Mandleson, only you can save us http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
dgwbirch
Wonder if Sarkozy’d send me a pirated copy of Up or Moon before he’s got disconnected to the ‘Net: http://cli.gs/7XnVT9
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
HendrikRunte
De minis infringement, but if it makes people feel better making a mountain out of a molehill then so be it.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
There is NO way in stopping it
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Internet Soldier
Do as I say and not as I do, Do as I say not as I do, Do as I say not as I do.
The government hypocrites, never! James Ross
Sarkozy en otro de sus despliegues de pendejez total: http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Heldraug
Die franz. Regierung hat ja das Three-Strikes-Gesetz #hadopi durchgewunken, ist aber selbst #raubkopierer http://tinyurl.com/ycmwhaz
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
fischoderaal
La presidencia francesa piratea 400 DVDs http://bit.ly/EeIgL . Hipocresía en estado puro.
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
unforgiven_too
People, let’s boycott Uganda till Nikolia pays fines for what he did. Lol
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
dumb texan
http://bit.ly/4elQ6Z Dank Hadopi müsste Sarkozy das Netz gesperrt werden.
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
A_Kasper
Wait, I have to ask this question:
Sarkozy (actually, someone in an office somewhere near his) makes 300 copies of something, and you guys are calling out the hit squads.
Yet, many of the people posting here have put movies, music, and whatnot that they don’t own the rights to on the internet, where perhaps millions of people have copied and profited from it.
Don’t you think maybe you should call the hit squads on yourself first?
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Anonymous Coward
Nicolas Sarkozy violated his own copyright law http://is.gd/4eFkc
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
mlopezt
Yet, many of the people posting here have put movies, music, and whatnot that they don’t own the rights to on the internet, where perhaps millions of people have copied and profited from it.
Well, first, I haven’t done any of that… but the point isn’t that making copies is bad. The point is that if you’re going to claim making copies is bad and then pass laws that go against those who make copies… and then it turns out that you are illegally making copies, shouldn’t those laws apply to you first?
I would think that was sorta common sense. The people aren’t arguing that the "hit squads" are a good thing. They’re just using them to show the hypocrisy from Sarkozy.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Mike Masnick
It’s time to revisit IP law. I’m reusing the same words that someone else created. I have a quote in my e-mail sig, who should I talk to about paying royalties? I just downloaded Audacity and edited a nice ringtone for my phone. I used a few seconds of Beatles music, and a few seconds of Ella Fitzgerald music. I’m not going to sell ringtones, is this personal use?
Where is the line drawn? Protection has mutated to control. It’s time to overhaul IP law from the ground up, else the present outdated mindset loses control because they refuse to adapt. When communication is available, information will flow. Intellectual property law will change, whether done in a controlled fashion, or having been forced to change because of the things that are reasonable and possible in the modern age of communication.
This comment was originally posted on http://techdirt.com/)“>Techdirt.
Sheesh
#HADOPI #Sarkozy Au dessus des lois, comme d’habitude. http://bit.ly/EeIgL
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Vincku
So if we use the same principle Galaxy is using and apply it to software, then I should be able to copy and distribute copies of Adobe Photoshop CS3, Microsoft Office 2007 and all previous versions of software that are no longer for sale by the creators.
Cool, I would support that kind of situation, but something tells me copyright holders other than Galaxy may disagree with them.
This comment was originally posted on http://www.zeropaid.com/)“>ZeroPaid.com
kopimi
*I meant Office 2003 nor 2007
This comment was originally posted on http://www.zeropaid.com/)“>ZeroPaid.com
kopimi
Portrait of the French Head of State as a pirate http://bit.ly/5n5zD A cautionary tale! For everyone still defending copyright, that is.
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
plsburydoughboy
RT @hackernewsbot:French presidency makes 400 unauthorized copies of DVD… http://bit.ly/4kOCHr #hadopi
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
golgote
Mr. SARKOZY might have some more work to do at home since the (very) rich do not seem to feel concerned by the law:
GROUPAMA, a French insurer, was caught in a $200 million software PIRACY case.
GROUPAMA argued that bank secrecy entitled it to limit the scope of Police investigations to a building that was not the place of the infraction… and the General Prosecutor of PARIS (illegally) ruled that they were right:
http://remoteanything.com/archives/groupama.pdf Pierre