Happy birthday Facebook Jabber/XMPP chat vaporware
A year ago this day, Facebook announced “Right now we’re building a Jabber/XMPP interface for Facebook Chat. In the near future, users will be able to use Jabber/XMPP-based chat applications to connect to Facebook Chat“. The news has been greeted positively in various places everywhere.
A year later, strictly nothing happened, and that silence has not gone unnoticed. Facebook has not even issued the slightest announcement, except a wishlist bug report comment by Charlie Cheever mentioning that “some people are working on this. It will probably be done in a few months. Sorry the timeline isn’t more clear“.
Is that all that a major player such as Facebook can do to interoperate with the rest of the instant messaging world ? Words with no deeds to back them up are very disappointing, especially from a player with ample means. Annoucements followed by complete silence are an even bigger blow to anyone’s credibility. Will Facebook step up to the plate ?
By federating with the rest of the XMPP world and especially with Google Talk, Facebook has an opportunity to make a huge splash in instant messaging in a rare case where their interests are aligned with their user’s. Why the silence ?
Maybe I should not be using Facebook at all. But it has been so successful at attracting the family, the non-geeks and the girls that I have settled for the compromise of using it while serving some constructive criticism. But I feel better at Identi.ca and Friendfeed…
17 responses to “Happy birthday Facebook Jabber/XMPP chat vaporware”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
A year already, shouldn’t Facebook XMPP chat be in beta by now? :-)
[…] Happy birthday Facebook Jabber/XMPP chat vaporware […]
While waiting for a Facebook XMPP interface, you can use the new XMPP-to-Facebook gateway @ xmpp:fb.jabbim.cz (requires to use a Jabbim JID).
This is a feature I’ve been anxiously waiting for, and it’s sad too because Facebook is more or less following in the steps of AOL and Microsoft regarding XMPP/Jabber support.
why facebook transport on jabber.cz doesn’t work?
How should we know ? And anyway, a Jabber transport does not provide the same facilities as native XMPP.
Does Facebook really want to be interoperable with the rest of the world?
FB’s business model is based on the value of private information people feed in themselves. If you can connect to the chat and eventually have more features from an account out of FB’s control, where do they make the money?
Hello, if anyone is interested in Jabbim’s Facebook gateway and can’t get it to work, you can join multi-user chat room jabber@conf.netlab.cz (that is room jabber on conf.netlab.cz).
There you can meet the guys developing and running the software.
Currently, the software is available only for users who are contributing financially to Jabbim’s operation.
But:
1) The software is going to be free/open-source by the end of the summer. So other XMPP/Jabber server operators will be able to run their own.
2) Jabbim might enable the service for everybody for a limited time.
Looking forward to an open release of a XMPP/jabber transport, since facebook seems to have dropped the ball on this
“Is that all that a major player such as Facebook can do”
It seems like its all a major player has to do. Why do they care about jabber users when that is probably an insignificant portion of their user base. It seems like companies like this eventually get big enough that they don’t have to worry about pleasing their users anymore.
Isn’t the model for this sort of thing: court the techies to win them over so they will make their grandparents, mothers and friends get on, then forget about them because you are making so much money on advertising revenue from their grandparents, mothers, and friends?
Anyway, probably not true and just a bunch of cynical hot air, but I’m in a cynical mood.
I am sure it all comes down to money. If they can make money on it, they would do it. I hope they do end up adding it one day. If they do not, it would be a big disappointment.
[…] A year later, strictly nothing had happened, and that silence has not gone unnoticed. Facebook has not even issued the slightest announcement, except a wishlist bug report comment by Charlie Cheever mentioning that “some people are working on this. It will probably be done in a few months. Sorry the timeline isn’t more clear“. […]
This NYTimes articles says “Facebook plans to announce that it has embraced Jabber.” But doesn’t offer a timeline.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/10/technology/internet/10social.html
and Facebook/Jabber is now live!
http://www.facebook.com/sitetour/chat.php
Happy Birthday! :)
Now we need people to pester AOL and Microsoft to provide their promised XMPP federation (and what happened with that deal Google had with Skype for them to federate?).
Facebook Chat Launches XMPP Support